Sifted

How We Sift

Every recipe and every site is judged the same way. Here’s what we look for.

Judging a recipe

  • Exact measurements, not guesses
  • A method that makes sense on paper
  • Comments from cooks who actually made it
  • Real photos of real food

Judging a site

  • Reliability across many recipes, not just one
  • How hard ads and pop-ups make it to cook from
  • A jump-to-recipe button, or a short preamble
  • No AI-generated photos passed off as real

Our verdicts

Make it
The best version we found. Follow it as written.
Good with tweaks
Worth making with the changes we note.
Sifted Blend
The best dinner came from combining recipes. We tell you which part to take from each.
Sifted out
Not worth your time, and we say why.

We never copy a recipe

We tell you which version to make and why, then send you to the cook who wrote it. They get the visit and the credit.

Get new finds by email

We’ll send you the best new finds when we add them. No life stories.